1 who is afraid of life after death. - Thanatophobia: obsessive fear of death. Real facts about the afterlife

Is there life after the death of the physical shell - this question worries many people. Especially those who think about their destiny in this world. Whatever the Soviet stereotypes that there is no place for spirituality in the modern world, society tirelessly strives for self-knowledge and study. Despite the introduction of the foundations of atheism into the masses. The worldview of mankind is looking for a connection both with the Divine and with the other world. In which every living being will probably fall after his death.

Of course, modern science strive by all means to refute the opinion about the existence of another dimension. But this question is raised not only by people of advanced age. The younger generation also wants to understand their existence. They also want to understand what awaits us after the soul leaves the body shell.

Why does a person have a fear of death

Each of us at least once feared for our own lives. All sorts of illnesses, internal experiences, the aggressive impact of society gave rise to thoughts of death. At the same time, causing a frantic desire to live and delay the last day as far as possible.

Why are we so afraid to leave this mortal world?

In fact, everything is conditioned by one's own "ego", which wants to continue earthly joys. In most cases, we are not so afraid for our lives as we are for those close to us. All experiences are fully justified, especially when it comes to the lives of their own children.

Not the last role is played by the fear of the unknown world. Perhaps everything will end on his deathbed. But it is quite real that beyond the boundaries of modern existence there is a parallel non-material Universe. We will look into this further.

Clinical death or acquaintance with the afterlife

Mankind is familiar with thousands of cases when a patient, being a few steps from his own death, saw something inexplicable. Being in a state of virtual coma, they observed not only the light at the end of the tunnel. But they also had the opportunity to see the deceased relatives. In addition, patients more than once spoke about the feeling of nirvana that they managed to experience. The pain subsided, the experiences subsided, and in the soul there was complete peace and harmony.

But long-buried close people forbade staying in such a state for a long time. They talked about the fact that it was not yet time to die, because the mission had not been completed. It was they who forced the soul to return to the body shell. After such visions, patients almost always came out of a coma. Vital forces were completely restored, but it was impossible to forget what he saw.

What Doctors Say About Clinical Death

Based on the foregoing, the opinion that the afterlife still exists takes place in the modern world. In addition, such cases were recorded both in our country and abroad. Of course, doctors have found confirmation of this phenomenon:

  • According to the famous psychologist Paiel Watson. In the moment clinical death a person remembers the first seconds of his birth. The tunnel is actually a 10-centimeter birth canal, and not the so-called transition to the other world.
  • Resuscitator Nikolay Gubin put forward his no less interesting theory. All sorts of hallucinations are due to oxygen starvation. Along with cardiac arrest, the respiratory system of the body also stops working, which leads to toxic psychosis. At the same time, hallucinations can have different durations, and the motive of visions is set by the very subconscious of a dying person. The light at the end of the tunnel is the unwillingness to die. Meeting with the dead - longing and sorrow for them in reality. The flight of the soul over the body - numerous scenes from films that the patient decided to "try on" for himself.
  • Edinburgh hospital psychotherapist Chris Freeman also believes that absolutely all the pictures a person in a state of lethargic sleep saw during his lifetime in childhood, adolescence or more mature age.

Whatever the conclusions of doctors, I would like to believe in something mysterious. But to get an answer, you don’t want to go to the world of the dead at all. Perhaps we will be able to get one step closer to unraveling such an interesting mystery.

Life after death - research scientists

No matter how paradoxical it may sound, but the opinions of scientists regarding this issue forked. Some, after a series of trials, say with confidence that the afterlife exists. Others completely renounce this hypothesis, motivating it with a number of evidence.


Nevertheless, researchers from different countries and universities agree with the fact. That in the first seconds after cardiac arrest, the brain begins to generate electrical impulses to the fullest.

American scientists have denied the existence of the other world

California Institute of Technology led by students and their supervisors. Call on the world to stop believing the legend that the afterlife exists. Advanced physicists have conducted a series of quantum tests to detect at least some particles of the spirit. Research has not yielded fruitful results. After that, American scientists declared publicly. "Those who express the opinion about the separation of the soul from the body are simply misleading the audience of listeners."

In addition, Sean Carroll (professor at the California Institute) believed that the hovering of the spirit after death could only occur in that case. If consciousness would not be one with the physical shell.

The British are on the verge of phenomenal discoveries

An unusual experimental plot, which was conducted more than 5 years ago in a hospital in the English town of Southampton, made mankind believe in a miracle. Cardiologist Sam Parnio recorded all sorts of data about the well-being of patients who were able to get out of a clinical coma. Studying the phenomenon of "incorporeal sensations", the doctor made a conclusion. “Despite the countless stories of their patients, there is not a single medical confirmation of these phenomena.”

After such a banal conclusion, Sam decided to conduct research without leaving the hospital. For the first time in the history of medicine, the director refurbished the institution and made it more convenient for research procedures. Colored pictures were installed on the ceiling. The medical staff recorded everything that happens to a person after a cardiac arrest. The activity of the brain, the first seconds of returning to life, emotions, experiences, facial expressions and even gestures were recorded.

More than half of the respondents claim that they did not see bright drawings, but felt the influence of otherworldly energy. To describe this state in simple words, it was a pious feeling of complete peace. Recordings from the words of people who were on the verge of death gave a more complete and understandable picture of such an incomprehensible phenomenon. Most of them are not afraid to die at the moment, but still want to live. Many have devoted themselves to charity, dedicating themselves to those in need.

Rebirth of the soul or "Reincarnation"


Reincarnation literally translates as "secondary rebirth into a new bodily flesh." The transition from the old state to the new, the working off of one's own karma, the evolution or degradation of consciousness - this is essentially what this tradition studies. Karma is the so-called mechanism that a person launches during his lifetime by his actions, thoughts and even words spoken during his existence.

After death, it is believed that souls reside in different worlds, moving from one level to another. In order for the spiritual component to move to a new, more high level. She needs to master centuries of experience. Each incarnation (rebirth) has its own program, which is derived with the help of karma from a past life lived. At the same time, the soul of the deceased can be reborn in a different era, poor or rich living conditions. As a result, the transitions from life to life can raise the consciousness to the highest level. At this stage, the soul can break out of the cycle of endless reincarnations and move into an endless bohemian world.

If the soul does not develop, but rather degrades, it is destined to wander. The reason for low levels in most cases is that a person does not look for a goal in life, does not know his own path, and puts material wealth first. Power, fame and money undoubtedly affect the quality of life. But do not forget about good deeds, which will add a considerable plus to your own karma.

Reincarnation - truth or fiction of a fool

Now it is difficult to say exactly when the opinion about the rebirth of the soul of the deceased into the body of an infant was born. But historians say that even the inhabitants of ancient Babylon believed that the human soul is immortal. According to their beliefs, death was not the end, but rather the birth of a new life. This private philosopher Maurice Jastrov repeatedly wrote about this in his teachings on infinite existence.

The emerging Babylonian opinion took root in the sciences of India. Indian philosophers contributed to the spread of the idea that reincarnation is based on the laws of karma. The concept of cycles of rebirth has found a place in moralizing in every corner of the planet.

At the moment, interest in revival has increased dramatically in European countries. Philosophical religions and oriental rituals became interested not only in the younger generation, but also in world famous personalities. Many psychotherapists use the so-called "past life therapy" in their practice.

With the help of hypnosis, they try to restore pictures from the patient's past life. Such methods allow to identify the causes of problems, behavioral patterns, diseases or phobias that have haunted the patient since birth.

Numerous surveys have shown that every fourth inhabitant of the planet believes in the rebirth of the soul. And every 8th saw pictures from the past existence. Moreover, mankind knows numerous proofs of this phenomenon.

Small children, being in a state of sleep, described the events that happened to them once. Some have explained foreign language, told their parents about their death and living conditions. In some cases, preschool children described historical events that they allegedly witnessed.

A skeptical view of reincarnation

Despite the fact that these teachings are actively promoted by Buddhist and Jewish philosophers, it is very difficult to find clear evidence of reincarnation. The theory of the eternal cycle is strongly rejected by modern researchers. The media also try to adhere to the traditional opinion - reincarnation is actually a pseudoscience that misleads society.

Additional video:

At the same time, hypnotic visions are explained by the fact that the psychotherapist, influencing the subconscious, sets the program himself, after which the patient can see certain events. Due to false memory and hypnotic influence, people may claim to have visited another planet and even had contact with extraterrestrial beings. Experienced skeptics assure that these are just tests, and a person in this case acts as a "guinea pig".

Phobias and all sorts of fears come from childhood - most professors think so. Gifts, talents and others Creative skills- the merit of the parents, and not at all a trace of past lives. Man is a trusting creature, which is easy to inspire with any information. Skillful philosophers were able to introduce into the minds the judgment of eternal life, because who would not want to believe in a miracle?

Life after death - Esoteric


Another opinion regarding this issue is that we do not consist of only one physical shell. We are created from several thin materials, folded according to the principle of an old Russian toy. The level closest to us is ether or astral matter. This means that we simultaneously exist both in several dimensions - in the material and. To maintain vital processes, it is necessary to eat and drink clean water properly.

In the spiritual astral plane, everything is different - it is necessary to maintain contact with the Universe and not harm the environment. Subject to these rules, a person will be able to receive energy for new achievements and reach peaks in all his endeavors.

Death stops the existence of the densest matter - the body. From the physical shell at the moment of cessation of the work of all vital organs, the soul breaks out, which can only have a connection with the Cosmos. People who have experienced a complete cardiac arrest describe only a close level of outer space, because astral matter is not yet fully aware of the fact of death and is rushing about in search of explanations.

After doctors ascertain death, subtle matters gradually move away from a person. On the 3rd day after dying, the ether is separated, which is called the aura in the common people. 9th or 10th day - disintegration of emotional matter, 40th - disintegration of the mental body.

After forty days, the casual body goes to wander between the worlds until they get to where they have been prepared for a place. The grief of relatives, their tears and lamentations do not have the best effect on the state . Due to destructive emotions, they cling between worlds and may remain there.

Unsettled souls and séances

Many occultists believe that after dying, souls pass into another world. This world is unearthly and located far beyond the galaxy. Since the souls are non-material, their further refuge also has no space, time and boundaries. But only those people who have completed their mission on Earth and left in due time can get into the world of the dead.


Esotericism claims that suicides remain wandering among the living, being in eternal torment. Those who died on their own violated one of the laws of the universe. There is no place for such people among those who humbly endured earthly cares and waited for their end. The slain also remain unsettled, but only until the moment when his killer is punished.

It is believed that if human justice does not punish your hands in blood, you will receive punishment from above. Only after the spirit of the deceased with a violent death is convinced of this, he goes to his dead relatives in the world of eternal bliss.

AT occult sciences there are known practices for calling the spirit into our world - spiritualistic seances. The cause of paranormal phenomena is not exactly known, but psychics and esotericists claim that they have learned to keep in touch with the souls of the dead. In this they are helped by magical accessories and, of course, the gift of clairvoyance, which not everyone can master.

Whatever the moral teachings of various sciences, every person would like to believe in the immortality of the soul. And after his own death, to meet with his loved ones, who wanted to say so much during their lifetime.

Everyone will be able to reliably learn about the existence of the afterlife, but unfortunately we will not be able to tell about it.

Answers your questions: Paratrooper, fought in Afghanistan. A wound in the head, as he writes to himself, blew off half of the skull. After the operation, the memory was partially unlocked.
He about himself: There was no clinical death. I had surgery on my head (4 hours). They gave anesthesia, "left" and ... ended up in a room where 3 some kind of beggars were sitting at the table. Considering my "case", they explained that I was now "on pause", i.e. 1 earth second is eternity. To the question: "Where is it here?" with a sly smile, they answered that on Earth, only in its two hundred or so parallel level.
Reality - 100% (the most interesting thing is that I was in my clothes, but I was lying naked on the operating table). I was told that my contract provides for a 2nd instant incarnation. There were 2 options: either "turn it on" or turn it off on Earth and attack into a lower purgatory. I chose the 1st... Then I ended up in a terrible place. I had only vision and thoughts, nothing else. There was no memory. I didn't know who I am? and where am I? Ignorance gave rise to wild horror. The space was multidimensional, alive. Colors are white and all shades of red. I assume that it was a glitch from anesthesia. After an eternity, I opened my eyes and remembered everything - not only the operation, but who I was and where I came from, I remembered the Abrenocenter, the House and my cosmic name. Unfortunately, the next morning, like many other things, I forgot it. After the operation, there was no time to write, and I didn’t think that the unlocked memory would begin to close so quickly. Until a headache, he tried again to remember his own, and not earthly, name and ... could not. I only remember that it was short. "That" memory closes over the years, but I learned the most important thing for myself. I started my 2nd incarnation (with a "defeat" in rights and a change in life). Friends disappeared, tastes changed. 2 incarnations in 1 life - so as not to waste Time ... On my palms - along the 2nd line of life.

1) Is it suicide to seek death by doing dangerous work or life-threatening sports?
This is not suicide, this is a departure from the tasks assigned to you. Placed by whom? By yourself - even before a business trip ... They fly to Earth to shed imper (negative energy), and because this purgatory is karmic, then all the “business travelers” earn Karma and tie knots that need to be “untied” (peacefully) or “cut”. For example, almost all domestic and criminal murders are a failure by the killer of his karmic scenario. These people were specially placed in conditions when the knot tied by them earlier had to be untied (score "5") or cut (score "2").
I was taken in the wrong direction... Actually, everyone has different tasks (later you will learn about your own in the Karma Department), they are connected mainly with Karma. But one task for everyone is not to break the commandments and not to sin (i.e. not to collect the Earth imperil instead of resetting the Home one) and not to try to escape from here... A person is sent here, for example, for 58 years. And he, doing extreme sports, breaks into a "cake" at the age of 20 (not having time to drop the imperil). He is returned here for 38 years, but not immediately, but until 70 years have passed here. Time is wasted, and there are a lot of "hemorrhoids" ...

2) Is it suicide if not treated for some deadly disease?
No, no, it’s not ... It’s the same as considering the defense of the Motherland in the war as suicide (many soldiers die). Chronic alcoholism and drug addiction are suicide (although working out for them will be easier than for physical suicides).

3) Is reincarnation such an invention of the human mind, in which there is logic, but there is no sense?
People who have at least 7-9 business trips to this planet do not have such questions (they intuitively feel that they live here not for the first, and, perhaps, not the last time). If you asked such a question, then it’s definitely not the first time, but no more than 3 ...

4) Why is the choice always one-sided in any religion - either you obey it, or you go to hell?
And you are already in Hell!... And although this Hell is of "general regime" and with resort conditions, this does not change the essence. Obey the rules or you will be lowered... even lower, into more severe purgatory.
On Earth, there is still freedom of choice (do not obey), below - it will not be ... Of the 9 purgatories, we are at the top (9th). So, there is still room to “fall” ... By the way, progress is not alien to the “devils”. They haven't been frying anyone in pans for a long time. The process of beating the dope out of sinners is automated and computerized, which "pleasantly" surprises novice sinners (they immediately demand the return of a more "humane" frying pan). After all, the Earth is not the "Center of the Universe" and not the "cradle and light" of the Universe, but the most common prison (Base-purgatory, if scientifically).

5) The female soul in the male body. What is it in terms of reincarnation? Punishment or error?
Women's souls enter only into women's bodies, men's into men's. If a person feels like a person of the opposite sex, then one of the energies (Yin or Yang) has "blocked oxygen" in him. This is a karmic punishment (to be in the "skin" of someone over whom he has been scolding for several lives).

6) Life on Earth was brought from outer space, what do you think?
Earth does not belong to the monadic planets on which life spontaneously arises. Life here was brought by the Sirius civilization (by the way, all Japanese come from there).

7) I often read somewhere that we ourselves choose where to be born, when, and with whom ... And I just can’t understand why then children choose drunk parents, sadistic parents, and so on. , all in the same vein. If there was a choice, then why did they doom themselves to suffering?
Those who have not sinned in terms of choice have a complete "carte blanche". For sinners, the more sins, the less choice. It is the drunks and sadists who were such in a past life that are sent to drunks and sadists.

8) How to sell your soul to the devil?
There are things that are dangerous to joke with!!! You were joking, but "Bottom" has already taken note of you ...

9) Why??.. Here you fight.. like a fish on ice.. but there is no result?
So, there is no access there ... you are not allowed to do this.

10) Why are suicides not accepted in heaven? Or do they still accept, but somehow especially?
To Heaven for all of us - as to China with cancer (even further). From this purgatory, everyone returns Home - to the same physical-material world, like the Earth. EVERYONE will return, only sinners (including suicides) will return much, much later

11) Why are suicides weak people for you?
Whoever you ask, everyone thinks that way. And no one thought how bad it was for them... Apparently, hopelessness made them take such a step... They cannot be called weak... And, of course, a lot depends on the environment; their indifference increases the number of suicides ... If it were possible to show potential suicides what awaits them after death, then 99% would refuse this undertaking (all earthly "problems" would immediately seem like Paradise to them, I'm not kidding). If the person did not pass the "test", then in the next. attempt (after Hell) he will again be put in the same situation, but the "rules of the game" will become tougher ... After 3 "failures" the Triatom's "fuse" will work - pers. will be born without arms and legs (or paralyzed) and will not physically be able to commit suicide...

12) Is it true that if there is a close suicidal relative in the family, then this carries a negative for the whole family and what kind?
The truth is that everyone who "contacted" with a suicide in the last year and a half or two years of his life (whether relatives or friends) will be punished for his sin. They may not go to hell, like a suicide, but in the future it will not seem enough to them. They will not believe me, but not a single suicide occurs spontaneously - on a spiritual level, a person makes such a decision 2 years before ... and it is impossible not to notice the change in 2 years. It is the environment that can prevent sin, if .... wants.

13) Is Jesus Christ a man or an alien from unknown worlds?
He was the most ordinary person, like all other people. It's just that "Above" he was given a "task" (from there they worked miracles for him) ... And there are no aboriginal people on Earth; we are all aliens...

14) What are you striving for? The purpose of your life path? Where are you going? Why did you come into this world, do you think?
Came (like everyone else) to be cleansed. Of course, in purgatory it is not forbidden to "evolve" and "learn", only....they don't send a whole Soul here. Then our Triat will dissolve in it and everything Earthly will become a damn thing to us ...

15) Children's sins are forgiven, right? They frighten me here that I will burn in the fire and everything is so unpleasant. Until how many years is it goodbye?
Karma begins to "work" at the age of 12-14. Parents are responsible for children's sins, if they are not, then the environment of the child (for his crimes, these adults go to hell; I'm not kidding) ... But their egregors people. begins to fill with energy "+" and "-" from birth (this energy is generated by any thoughts, emotions and actions). This is the "fuel" for the next incarnation, which determines its quality (the more "minuses", the worse life is and vice versa). Young sinners do not go to hell, but thanks to egregors, their next life (childhood) turns into a nightmare (and illness is not the worst thing yet) ... With "repentance" it's not so simple either ... For example, repentance before death will not help (as they say, it's too late to rush about!) ...

16) Why does space have three dimensions and time one?
Because they were artificially set here like that. In the karmic world, there must be one temporary LINEAR dimension so that causal relationships are not violated (time in the form of a flowing river). There is no house of the laws of Karma, and time there is different (in the form of a stagnant lake). There are several time dimensions - undulating, pulsating, sprayed ... different. In the 3-dimensional Universe, almost all planets are lifeless. In the 4-dimensional Real (having millions of subspaces), life in our Universe is literally teeming, and the stars are located differently there.

17) I want to live in another country....
Even before birth, we ourselves choose (or "deserved" according to past incarnations) the place of birth and habitat. You can change the country, but ... avoiding one "test" can add 10 new ones ....

18) How do you feel about people who use drugs?
Drugs (any) are the invention of the Devil. Those who are addicted to them (who have accepted this “gift”) “sign” under certain “agreements”, in short ... you won’t envy their posthumous fate ... My attitude towards suicides is negative, or do you think that suicide is only physical self-destruction? ??
P.S. Alcohol "hollows" the brain and psyche, but at least it does not destroy the consciousness and Soul, as drugs do ... even very "light" .... even if rarely.

19) Is it possible to see your guardian angel in the astral plane? Has anyone seen who entered the astral plane?
The so-called "Guardian Angels" are ordinary people of flesh and blood who have already left the Earth (or are preparing to be sent here). Usually relatives or friends. You can see them in a dream (they do not fly in the astral plane - there are no wings). Everything in the astral plane is IMAGES, and even demons can create them...

20) Is there life after death and where do suicides end up?
After "death" the soul sees everything, hears, feels... flies like a bird (a month and a half). Then (in transit through the adaptation center) he returns home (from where he was sent here on a business trip). He wakes up in a physical body and ... a feast begins (with alcohol - after all, one must celebrate the return and meeting with relatives who were "lost" here ...). The memory remains, moreover, the cosmic memory is unlocked... There are no post-mortem flights for suicides - they are lowered several purgatories below (working out there is different for everyone). Having worked, let's say, in the 4th, they rise (with working out) in the 5th, etc. ... Until the "nine" -Earths rise, a lot of time will pass. They will return home, but later than others.

21) Is there justice? .. before God and before people ...
The laws of Karma operate on the Earth, and these are the Laws of Justice — when the balance of the energies "+" and "-" is equalized due to the one who violated it. It’s just that good or evil is rewarded to some immediately, and to others in the next life ...

22) How do you feel about reincarnation? Does she really exist? And what is its meaning?
There is, no doubt about it. In short, we are sent to this purgatory (from other MATERIAL worlds) to shed the imperil (negative energy). Dropped - returned home. Here 100 years pass, and there - about a month (relatives will not have time to get bored). You live there ("having turned off" time) for 50 - 500 - 1000 years (without aging, without getting sick) and again here - on a business trip ... Those who, instead of resetting, gained Earth imperil, are lowered lower - there time is even slower (compared to Earth - there is a real Hell). In total - 9 purgatory bases (not counting thousands of branches in their parallel worlds). "Nine" (Earth) - the very first and easiest. This is not an independent civilization, here even Time and Space are set artificially. "Incarnations" are not "Roly-Vstanka" (born-died-born-died...), they are short business trips to this planet...
Reserve incarnations are needed in order not to waste time on "death-birth". From here, after all, they do not immediately get home. In the parallel layers of the Earth there is a Huge Office, from where thousands of people (operators) watch us, there (in the "sanatorium") they bring to life all the ex-"dead". Depending on their sins, they are then sent Home, to Hell, or ... they work out on the spot, but many sinners "fly" from here to Hell immediately. Last time I did not get there, but I was almost never at Home either. Therefore, in a business trip contract, I signed a clause that I was "slowed down" in which case (contracts are different for everyone) ... Suicides mostly end up in 4-6 purgatory (and God has nothing to do with it), so I don't advise "running away" ...

23) Why are some able to survive the catastrophe, while others - seemingly just as strong - go to the bottom?
Because the time has not yet come for some, and for others it has already come - to leave the Earth ... Catastrophes, etc. - just decorations. If it's time for someone to leave, then even being in the safest place, he will ... leave.

24) Is it true that after death a person continues to live in the spiritual realm? What does God say about this?
Not true! After "death" you will be a spirit for only a month and a half, then you will wake up in your own physical body in a "sanatorium" located in the parallel world of the Earth. There is a religious department there, find its chief (for earthlings, he acts as God), do not be surprised if he is in torn jeans and with a can of beer in his hand. He will tell you that the real Creator cannot communicate with purgatory Earth and many spiritual knowledge was transferred from Above not to earthlings, but to MATERIAL civilizations Sirius, Dessa, Orion, Daya, Alpha and Vega, from which we are all sent here on business trips. It is for these worlds (and not for the Earth) that the Spiritual World is the ceiling. But earthly senses intercept this information and start scribbling "Revelations" that have nothing to do with the Earth... After the "sanatorium" everyone returns to their historical homeland, where one can live indefinitely. 90% of people consider the aforementioned civilizations to be a real Paradise and they are not in a hurry to rise to the Spiritual spheres, and not everyone is allowed there ....

25) There is a question. Who are the Aryans? And what modern people can be considered their descendants?
The first incarnants that appeared on Earth were from Dessa (most people lived there on the planet Aria, other planets were technical), so here they called themselves Aryans, Aryans .... Now the number of inhabited planets on Dessa has increased to 56th (the main one is Delta) and are sent here not from one, but from 5 civilizations. In 1941 most of the natives of Arya concentrated in Germany and the USSR, the cutting of the karmic knot (war) started by the Aryans back in the time of the "King Pea" began ...
Most Russians come from Dessa, so draw your own conclusions about where the Aryans live...

26) Civil marriages.
Such "marriages" are sinful, because the commandment "Do not commit adultery" is violated! (they have no help from Above)... In the karmic world, every little thing matters, incl. and the notorious "stamp" - this is spelled out in the "Travel Contract", which everyone signs before being sent to Earth.
If you have chosen the Dark Path, this is your right; wander further, only then don’t bother why some from this Purgatory are returned Home, while others (including you) will be lowered lower, where you can no longer decide anything .... There they will decide for you - in front or behind ... and everything would be fine, but there is one heavy "But" - these processes are not connected with pleasure in any way (and all the memory with the "+" sign will be blocked so that there is no Hope for everyone who enters it)...

27) Where do the gods disappear to?
Who are we? Children of God... In the third month of pregnancy, the Soul enters the mother's fetus, and the baby "comes to life". On the 40th day from birth, the Spirit Comes... And the child becomes Triune.
What then happens to our divine child? And then he gets into the dense earthly energies, first of his parents, then of school, then of the institute, society, society. First he cries, 26) Believers and unbelievers! How do you feel about civil marriage (in short, cohabitation)?
adapting and trying to maintain its integrity. And then he adapts, condenses his field in order to survive.... Gradually, his fine-structured components are detached, and by the age of 30 he becomes just an ordinary mortal person. Such are the things ... Is it possible to preserve the originality? Only by limiting the child from harsh educational measures, from pressure environment... only in an atmosphere of absolute harmony and love can you grow God out of a little man?

I'll fix it a little. The soul of a child enters the astral body of the mother (and not the fetus!!!) at the 2nd month, and for some even earlier. It enters the child on the 40th day after birth (approximately)... "Subtle constituents" do not come off from anyone... Earth is purgatory; and in them - suffering and death are natural ... even children, although they are not "children" at all (up to 14 years of age, no one is sent here) ... Almost all dead children are "signalmen", they are here for this and are sent to die so that at the moment of death they can pass on a higher vibrational code to their parents. But there are also "carriers"; they give their code on the "40" birthday. And then ... if they drink a little, smoke and swear, they will dock with the vibrations of the Earth (by the age of 25-30) and will live ... And if you bring them up "in harmony and love", then they will leave young ... In short, we are all Gods, only we are now in ... a "general regime colony".

28) There are only three options: Is Jesus God, a deceiver or a madman? What do you think?
All 3 options are wrong! 2000 years ago he was the same "God" as we all are with you. But he was never a deceiver and a madman (calling himself the Son of God, he did not deceive, because we are all sons and daughters of God) ... He, a mere mortal, wanted to go to the Spiritual world, and from Above he was told - to You still have an ununtied karmic knot on the Earth, until you untie it, we won’t let it go ... So he went on his last business trip to Earth (with a mission to load). And he was not the first, just ... other tortures and executions were frightened, and the mission (to give a new religion) seemed to many a bit heavy ... P.S. I'll probably be punished there, but... I'll say it anyway. Almost all the "miracles" were done not by Jesus, but by those who helped him from Above (not from the Spiritual world, but from the material House).

29) What happens to the soul after death?
A month and a half is on Earth (sees, hears, feels everything, instantly moves in space). Someone all these "40 days" hangs from the ceiling in his apartment (or ... over his grave, waiting for the "Last Judgment"), someone "sits" in the nightstand, someone "travels" the Earth. Then the "dead"... wakes up in his own physical body in the "Sanatorium" (an adaptation center in the parallel space of the Earth); old people come to life there at the age of forty. After adaptation, everyone is returned Home, to those civilizations from where they were sent here on a business trip. There, all the bodies will be different, but they will also be made of flesh and blood ...
Earth is not an independent civilization, but a closed purgatory with fake time and space. We are here temporarily (on a business trip). "Death" is the return Home, to the same material world...

30) Here is God, he cannot be immanent and transcendent at the same time?!
Explain to me: why turn to God? Will he listen and do something? It turns out that a person through prayers can control the actions of God? So which one is God then? Man CAN NOT control the actions of God? Moreover, why ask him to do something?

That God exists is a fact. From this purgatory, not a single person can communicate with God, just as convicts cannot communicate with the president; their letters will be read (and reviewed on behalf of the president) by the head of the colony. Our prison is watched by tens of thousands of people - those who play the role of "God", angels and saints, personal operators and departed relatives. If Karma allows, they help (like my wife), if not, they can't wait for help (like me)... Absolutely everything consists of energy. Obscene "bundles" and Prayers are energy MANTRAS; the first - destroy the Soul, the second - put the energy in order, while you cannot combine them (sin and pray); to explain for a long time... If a person asks something from God and receives it, then he is helped from Above (if allowed) by the same people, and not by God.... Yes, and God is not the most important commander in our Universe; he is only the head of the Light Ones (like the Devil over the Dark Ones). And the main one, who is called the Absolute (or Nature) ... P.S. Millions of dying and starving is normal for Purgatory #9. In the other 8 purgatories - a real hell, believe me ...

31) What is the difference between life before and after death?
And what kind of "death" are we talking about - Earthly, Cosmic or Monadic? If we talk about the Earth, then... how is your home different before leaving... to kindergarten, school, work,... and after coming out of them? Almost nothing... When they say that after Earth's "death" life continues in the form of energy, this is... part of the truth. After a month and a half (and those who died in the war - after 3 months), all these "" energies "come to life in their own physical body of flesh and blood, and the blind begin to see, the legless wake up with legs, etc. ... Ex -the priests begin to get everyone there with questions like, why wasn’t this in the Bible and where is the promised Paradise? But there are no angels...

32) If you could meet Jesus, what would you learn from him?
A couple of years ago (cosmic time) Jesus was the same person as we all ... He just wanted to move into a more upper world(there, at home, we all have such a right). But Upstairs they told him - you still have a joint on Earth (an untied karmic knot), you untie it, and at the same time complete the mission - give people a new religion ... Therefore, he did not avoid execution ... And no one didn't lie about the "Son of God," tk. we are all children of God...
I saw him ... but I'm not in a hurry to accomplish his feat ....

33) What do you think God will say to you at the end of your life journey?
The real God will not say anything (we are even further away from him than before China - cancer). For earthlings, "GOD" is the head of the religious department in the office that watches over the Earth. And what can he (in torn jeans and with a can of beer in his hands) tell us, demobilized people? Imagine a convict writes a letter to the president. But he will read it and give an answer (on behalf of the President) OFFICER. Also, from this purgatory, no one can communicate with the real God.... In order not to offend the feelings of believers, I will say that almost all churches are connected by energy channels to those Spiritual worlds that are much, much closer to God than the above-mentioned boss. ..

34) Does God punish or just leave unattended?
God does not punish. The laws of Karma operate on Earth (what you sow, so you reap). If the person jumps from the 5th floor and breaks his legs, will he blame God for this? No, because knows about the law of gravity (earth attraction). And the laws of Karma are exactly the same cosmic laws, only not physical, but energetic...

35) Is there life after death?
On Earth, “death” is a periodic change of “containers” for Triatoms (as we say), i.e., a change of fake physical receptacles for a real particle of the Soul. To be immortal at Home (in the absolutely material and physical world), you need to periodically "fly" to this purgatory and... "die" .... I swear to you - when you "die", then in 35-45 days you will wake up in the "Sanatorium" in your own body, and you will be met by relatives, "dead " earlier (if they want and if they are allowed). But the "Sanatorium" is not a Home, It is .... "Airport"; when you adapt there, you will be returned Home ...

36) Do you think there is another world?
There are an infinite number of them. And for those worlds, our world is also "other world". In fact, space and time on Earth are set artificially (there are several hundred artificial parallel worlds, branches of purgatory Earth, I mean not 4th and other dimensions, but 3rd dimensions). But the three-dimensional dimension is not Reality. And also on Earth - 1 temporary linear dimension (it's like the flow of a river), and in real life - time is pulsating, spiral, dotted (like a stagnant lake) ...

37) And 100, and 500, and 1000 years ago people lived on Earth, suffered, loved, thought, and today even their names have not been preserved? Isn't it a shame that the same thing will happen to us in 1000 years, and we will be forgotten? Or does nobody need it? And if it is not necessary, then maybe there is no point in living?
When you were 3-4 years old, you also "suffered, loved and thought." Are you drawn to that infancy time? If you pull (suddenly you are 10 years old?), then by the age of 50 it will stop pulling. Also, you will not give a damn about this earthly life when you return Home. Not a whole Soul is sent to the Earth, but only a billionth part of it - Triat; upon return, the microscopic earthly "I" will dissolve in a huge Soul so much that the Earth will cease to excite you ... Of course, many THERE (including me) have a "collection" of earthly business trips, but the main thing in them is not by whom and where I was born here, and what good did I do ....
P.S. With all the "Earthlings" (familiar and not so) you will meet at home

38) Does anyone know a way not to grow old? What about living forever? or at least 150-300 years ....
You know very well this way - to be forever young and healthy, for this you went to Earth. Just don't remember it for the time being. According to earthly chronology, I am hundreds of billions of years old, but there, at Home, my real body, which is in a lulled state in the storage of bodies, is only 28 years old. Even if I die here at the age of 98, I will still wake up there at the age of 28 .... I think you will not be more than that there either, although ... no one will forbid you to be there forever 18 years old ... You know everything as well as I do, it's just that your memory (as well as others) was blocked before being sent to Earth. People "fly" here not to get younger and healthier here, but to be forever such (and IMMORTAL) at Home; for Russians - on Dessa (the constellation Cygnus, 56 inhabited planets). 100 years pass here, and about a month there, so your relatives, who remained at Home, will not miss you especially ... The desire to prolong one's existence in this prison (in the "Trash of the Universe") is caused by the fear of death or the lack of faith in immortality... Earth is not an independent planet, but a closed purgatory of several civilizations, so be patient and don't worry. The motherland will not forget you!... By the way, there is a museum of the Earth on Dessa (life-size)...

39) The husband sends her for an abortion ... My daughter is 14, pregnant at 5 weeks, we rent an apartment with her parents, she says that we will never buy our own housing if there is a second child, I don’t think so, there will be no difference with one either, but here also maternity capital will be able to help with housing, I think. I want a baby, what should I do?
At the 5th week, the soul of the child is already in the astral body of the mother. If you have an abortion, where will this soul live in 9 months? According to local laws, this soul will be taken away by "blacks"; having pumped her up with "fuel oil", they will put her in the body of some drunkard. This is how killers are born... How can you then look into the eyes of your murdered child, and those whom he killed?...

40) What is better to be GOOD or EVIL?
Yes, everything is dual (even God and the Devil). But the Earth is the purgatory of the Light civilizations.. Only the Light ones are sent here (to reset the imperil, the energy that you call "evil"). The remaining 8 bases were created for those who, instead of resetting, on the contrary, gained earthly imperil (compared to Earth, it’s a real hell there, and not only murderers and robbers get there) ... And it’s also beneficial to be kind, because what kind of energy you pump into Egregors, this will be the quality of your next business trip (from bad "fuel" it will not be good) ...

41) What do you think is on the outskirts of space?
There begins another space (with other "parameters"). The number of universes is infinite. Yes, yes, there was Big Bang", but not 13 billion years ago. People discovered our planet 15 billion years ago (according to terrestrial reckoning), and there were already signs of life on it. In 100 years, you will all be very surprised to learn that the speed of light is not the same everywhere (some - where the light generally stands still), and our three-dimensional world is not reality. In the real real world, stars and constellations are not at all where they are seen by earthly astronomers

42) Have you ever thought about what will happen to us after death? Where will we be and will we ever...?
I didn't think so. I know perfectly well what will happen ... At first, you fly invisible for a month and a half (many all this time hang in their apartment under the ceiling or “sit” somewhere in the nightstand, and I won’t even look at my funeral - I’ll immediately fly to other countries " study"). Then, from a month to six months, you will have to spend in a "sanatorium" (many, having come to their senses there, do not believe that they have died, because everyone has earthly bodies, and they feed them the same cutlets). And then our sinful Triatoms return Home (our real physical bodies and Souls are now there in a sleepy state)... When I return, I will celebrate this event with relatives and friends for a long time... Because there are no spirits and angels... Because everything there is made of flesh and blood ... Because the Earth is just a purgatory, where even time and space are not real ...

43) One thing I could never accept, if a person is the pinnacle of perfection, why are there so many all kinds of freaks among us: in physical, mental and moral forms?
What other peak?... In the multidimensional Infinity, for those who are "below" we may be cool, but for those who are "up" we are just insects...

44) Is the death of the body the recovery of the soul?
Yes, yes, it is .... For this, we are all sent here, to Terra Purgatory (sorry, to Earth). I have already answered many many times here - in order to be forever young, healthy and immortal at Home, you need to periodically fly here on business trips and ... die. And another way to reset the empire from the soul has not yet been invented. They didn’t understand me .... And you don’t need to understand that our real physical bodies and Souls are now in a lulled state on Dessa, and only Triatoms are sent here, and even after “death”, after 35-45 days we come to our senses in Adapte not in their earthly bodies (as it seems to everyone), but only in their copiers .... P.S. From here we cannot get to Paradise, first we need to return Home, only there is no money, violence, lonely and .... Claves ( cemeteries)...

45) Why so? Everything is going well in your life, and at that moment fate appears and puts your life in cancer.
There are no accidents; What goes around comes around. Yes, often a person sows 5 lives ago and now does not understand (does not remember) why he got it like that ... In one Asian country, I heard a cynical, but essentially true saying - Do not condemn a soldier who stabbed a child with a bayonet, because . in the next life, a bayonet will also be stuck in this soldier (who will be a baby), and do not feel sorry for the murdered child, because, in a past life, being a soldier, he stabbed another child.

46) How do you know where you will go to Heaven or Hell, if the next world is judged not only by deeds and words?
About 20 years ago, my cosmic memory was partially unlocked, and such issues (including religious ones) stopped bothering me. The funny thing is that we are all already in Hell, because. Earth is purgatory (the most "humane" of all). Just don't talk about millions of happy earthlings, billionaires, and so on. That's all - until the first "hemorrhoids", the first maniac, the first stroke ... (when you return Home, where there are no diseases, old age, death, crimes, there are no duties and there is a right to everything, you will feel the difference). No one will judge, all the more so, not the Soul is sent here, but only its particle - the Triat. After the Earth, sinners are sent to more terrible purgatory not by God and the Devil, but by the mechanisms of certain laws (if a person put his fingers into the socket and was electrocuted, then one cannot say that she condemned and punished ..). And those who have returned judge themselves. When the memory of the ex-dead is opened in the posthumous "sanatorium", then their consciousness (essence-conscience) expands a thousand times - some, remembering what they did here, beat their heads against the wall (figuratively). You cannot get to Paradise from here, first I have to return Home... although... compared to the Earth... it's almost... And I won't go to Hell, because. I know the "rules of the game". And you're right - for many, Hell begins here.

47) Is there a meaning to life if we die anyway?
About 20 years ago, after a severe traumatic brain injury, I came to my senses and ... remembered why I was sent to Earth and where I would return later. The shock was so strong that I began to tell everyone about it, but ... no one believed. Imagine that the Earth is a prison, a purgatory. What kind of self-improvement can there be in prison, given that it is not our Souls that are sent here, but only their microscopic particles — Triatoms? Of course, there, on Dessa, Sirius, Orion, Daya, Alpha ... trillions of times better - there are no diseases, old age, death, no crimes, no lonely people, no money (everything you need, you get for free). In general, 90% of people consider these material worlds as Paradise and are in no hurry to become "Angels". But in order to live there forever, you need to periodically go on business trips to Terra Purgatory, where you are now ... My advice to you all is to keep the commandments, and then you will live at Home for hundreds, thousands of years (until the next business trip) and have everything, oh what you only dreamed of ... Those who have abortions cheat (about suicides, murderers, thieves, scammers, etc. I generally keep quiet), At home they will rest for a couple of weeks and ... again to Earth in worse conditions, or - "formatting" Personality.

48) And then they will make sure that people do not die at all? Well, after... many many many years... Scientists will be able to do that?
In my homeland, Desse (where most Russians come from) used to die. Then scientists (not ours, but peep-eyed ones, from Sirius) discovered that there is only one way to get rid of diseases, old age and death - to drop imperil (negative energy). But it can be dropped only in very gross material worlds. It was there that the purgatory bases were created to reset the imperil. The Earth is one of such bases... It's a paradox - to be immortal at Home, you need to periodically fly here on business trips and die here... All of you are business travelers, just don't remember it... yet. The immortality of the House is to be forever young (20-30 years old) and never get sick. And overpopulation does not threaten there, because. we can revive any planet (there are 56 habitable planets on Dessa).

Part 1 is here. It can be assumed that of all scientific disciplines, it is philosophy that should be most interested in research into the phenomenon of near-death experiences (NDEs) and carefully study them. After all, doesn't philosophy deal with questions of higher wisdom, the meaning of life, the relationship between the body, consciousness, and God?

Near-death experiences provide data that are directly related to all of these questions. How is it possible that philosophy has managed to collectively ignore and even ridicule these studies? To those who are not connected with academic philosophy, it may seem incredible that the vast majority of academic philosophers are atheists and materialists. Incorrectly using science to support their materialism, they systematically ignore scientific evidence that refutes their worldview.

Even more surprising is that even those philosophers who are not materialists (and their number, I think, is growing) refuse to look at these data. One might assume that Cartesian dualists or Platonists would greedily seize on data that convincingly supports their view that consciousness is superior to the physical world, but this is not the case.

To my surprise, he was as skeptical as my fellow fundamentalist. When I asked him why he was not interested, he replied that his beliefs in God, the afterlife, etc. based on faith; if these things were proven empirically, then there would be no room for faith, which is the basis of his religious beliefs.

I realized that PSPs are caught between two fires because they are not taken seriously by the two sciences, philosophy and theology, which should be interested in this phenomenon. As soon as theology and religion open the door to empirical data, there is a danger that these data may contradict some aspects of faith. Indeed, it did.

PSP data, for example, says that God is not vengeful, he does not punish or condemn us, and is not angry with us for our "sins"; of course, there is condemnation, but, in this all the stories about the PSP agree, this condemnation comes from the individual himself, and not from the Divine Being.

It seems that all God can give us is unconditional love. But the concept of an all-loving, non-punitive God runs counter to the teachings of many religions, so it's no surprise that religious fundamentalists don't feel comfortable.

Strange Allies

Over the years, I have come to the conclusion that both the atheist and the believer, from the fundamentalist to the fundamentalist, have something in common. Indeed, from an epistemological point of view, this commonality is much more important than where their views differ. They agree on the following: beliefs relating to the possible existence of a transcendental reality - God, soul, afterlife, etc. are based on faith, not facts. If so, then there can be no actual evidence to support these beliefs.

The belief that belief in a transcendental reality cannot be empirically verified is so deeply rooted in our culture that it has the status of a taboo. This taboo is very democratic because it allows everyone to believe what they want to believe. This allows the fundamental materialist to feel comfortable, being convinced that the mind is on his side, that there is no afterlife, and those who believe otherwise have fallen victim to irrational forces, wishful thinking. But it also allows the fundamentalist to feel comfortable believing that God is on their side, and those who think otherwise have fallen prey to the forces of evil and the Devil.

Thus, although the fundamentalist and the fundamental materialist take extreme opposite positions on the question of the afterlife, these extreme positions unite them as "strange allies" in the fight against the actual evidence of the afterlife that empirical research can find. The very suggestion that empirical research can confirm beliefs in a transcendental reality contradicts this taboo and threatens many elements of our culture.

Meaning of life

The study of the PSP has led to the following unequivocal conclusion: those who have experienced the PSP confirm the core values ​​common to most of the world's religions. They agree that the purpose of life is knowledge and love. A study of the transformative impact of NSP shows that cultural values ​​such as wealth, status, material things, etc. are becoming much less important, and eternal values ​​such as love, caring for others, and the divine are becoming more important.

That is, the study showed that PSP survivors not only verbally proclaim the values ​​of love and knowledge, but also try to act in accordance with these values, if not completely, then at least to a greater extent than before PSP.

As long as religious values ​​are presented as simply religious values, it is not difficult for popular culture to ignore them or mention them in passing during a Sunday morning sermon. But if those same values ​​are presented as empirically verified scientific facts, then everything will change. If the belief in an afterlife is accepted not on the basis of faith or speculative theology, but as a confirmed scientific hypothesis, then our culture will not be able to ignore it. In fact, this will mean the end of our culture in its present form.

Consider the following scenario: further research on the PSP confirms in detail what has already been found; more cases of confirmed authentic "out-of-body" experiences have been collected and documented; advanced medical technology makes even more cases of the “smoking gun” type described above possible; the study of those who experienced PSP confirms the already noted change in their behavior associated with newly acquired (or recently strengthened) spiritual values, etc. Studies are duplicated in different cultures with the same results.

Finally, the weight of the actual evidence begins to show, and scientists are ready to announce to the world, if not as a fact, then at least as a sufficiently confirmed scientific hypothesis:

(1) Afterlife exists.

(2) Our true identity is not our body, but our mind or consciousness.

(3) Although the details of the afterlife are not known, we are sure that everyone will have a re-examination of his life, during which he will experience not only every event and every emotion, but also the consequences of his behavior, positive or negative. The usual defense mechanisms by which we hide from ourselves our sometimes cruel and unmerciful attitude towards others do not seem to operate during life review.

(4) The meaning of life is love and knowledge, learn as much as possible about this world and the transcendental world, and increase our ability to feel kindness and mercy towards all living beings.

(5) Harming others, both physically and psychologically, will turn out to be a great nuisance to us, since any pain that has been caused to others will be experienced as one's own during the revision.

This scenario is by no means contrived. I believe there is enough evidence to present the above statements as "likely" and "more possible than not". Further research will only increase this possibility.

When this happens, the effect will be revolutionary. When science announces these discoveries, it will no longer be possible to do business in the same way as before. It would be interesting to speculate on what an economy would look like if it tried to fit the five empirical hypotheses above, but that is beyond the scope of this article.

The discoveries of PSP researchers will mark the beginning of the end of a culture driven by greed and ambition, which measures success in terms of material wealth, reputation, social status, and so on. Consequently, modern culture has a huge interest in hindering research on PSP by ignoring, refuting, and downplaying research findings.

I will end the article with a short story. Charles Broad, writing in the mid-20th century, was President of the British Society for Physical Research. He was the last philosopher with an international reputation who believed there was something to it. Towards the end of his life, he was asked how he would feel if he found that he was still alive after the death of his physical body. He replied that he would rather be disappointed than surprised. Wouldn't be surprised since his research led him to conclude that the afterlife most likely exists. Why disappointed? His answer was disarmingly honest.

He said he lived good life: he was financially secure and enjoyed the respect and admiration of his students and colleagues. But there is no guarantee that his status, reputation and wealth will be preserved in the afterlife. The rules by which success is measured in the afterlife may be quite different from the rules by which success is measured in this life.

Indeed, PSP research suggests that Charles Broad's fears are well-founded, that "success" by otherworldly standards is measured not in terms of publications, merit, or reputation, but in kindness and compassion for others.

Used with permission from the Journal of Near-Death Studies.

Neil Grossman holds a PhD in history and philosophy from Indiana University and teaches at the University of Illinois, Chicago. He is interested in Spinoza, mysticism and the epistemology of parapsychological research.

Researchers ask the question: “How can the phenomenon of near-death experience be explained?” In doing so, they usually imply that any acceptable explanation must be expressed in terms of concepts - biological, neurological, psychological, with which they are already familiar.

The near-death experience (NDE) phenomenon could be explained if, for example, it could be shown which state of the brain, which drugs or which beliefs cause it.

Those who believe that PSP cannot be explained mean that it cannot be related to any physical or psychological state.

I want to state that this approach to explaining PSP is fundamentally wrong. As far as I know, no one who has experienced PSP feels the need to explain it in the simplified form that the researchers offer. For the PSP survivor, this needs no explanation, for it is exactly what it is. It is at least a direct experience of consciousness or mind or ego or personal identity - existing independently of the physical body. And only in relation to our deeply rooted materialistic paradigm does the PSP need proof, or rather, proof of its impossibility.

The falsity of materialism has been empirically proven; hence what needs to be explained is the collective refusal of academia to look at the facts and accept them for what they are. Today, academia is in the position of the bishop who refused to look through Galileo's telescope. Why is this happening?

Before answering this question, I want to talk about the nature and strength of the facts that refute materialism. In an article published in the Journal of Scientific Exploration in 1998, Emilia Williams Cooke, Bruce Grayson, and Ian Stevenson described "the three hallmarks of PSP - increased mental activity, the ability to see the physical body from a different position in space, and paranormal perception." They then described 14 cases that met these principles.

From an epistemological point of view, the third criterion, paranormal perception, is the most important. A materialist may, in principle, not explain how a person receives reliable information about events while outside the body.

Consider, for example, the case where the PSP tester accurately recounts a conversation that took place in the waiting room while his body was unconscious in the operating room. Relevant information transmitted in the form of sound or light waves could not leave the reception area, pass through the corridors and climb up the elevators to reach the sense organs of an unconscious person. However, the person wakes up after the operation with the information.

This case (there are many) shows quite directly that there are non-physical ways in which the mind can receive information. This leads to the conclusion that materialism is a false doctrine.

smoking pistol

Perhaps one such case is the "smoking gun" that Michael Sabom described in his book Light and Death. In this case, the patient experienced PSP when her body temperature dropped to 60 degrees F and her body was completely bled.

“Her electroencephalogram was silent, there was no reaction of the brain, blood did not enter the brain.” In this state, the brain cannot create any experiences. However, the patient reported a deep PSP.

Those materialists who believe that consciousness is a product of the brain, or that the brain is necessary for conscious experience, cannot explain such cases in terms of their own concepts. An unbiased observer would have to conclude that not all sensations are produced by the brain, and that materialism has been empirically proven to be false. What needs to be explained, therefore, is the extreme failure of academia to consider the evidence and conclude that materialism is a false theory, and consciousness can and does exist independently of the body.

Moreover, PSP is not the only evidence refuting materialism, there are many in other areas of research. Both spiritualism, which has been extensively studied since the time of William James, and the authentic cases described by Stevenson of children remembering their past lives, are replete with facts against materialism.

The best epistemological analysis of such evidence comes from Robert Almeder. After a lengthy and detailed discussion of past life memories, he concluded that "it is rational to believe in reincarnation, given the facts." The correct conclusion, according to Almeder, should be: "It is unreasonable not to believe in reincarnation, given the facts." I agree with Almeder.

Our collective unreasonableness about the wealth of facts that refute materialism manifests itself in two ways: (1) by ignoring the facts, and (2) by insisting on too strict standards of factual evidence, which, if accepted, would make any empirical science impossible.

Dogma and ideology

“Drug-induced hallucinations”, “the last glimpse of a fading brain”, “people see what they want to see” - these were the most common phrases. One conversation particularly made clear to me the fundamental irrationality of pundits regarding the evidence that refutes materialism. I asked, “What about the people who accurately described the details of their operation?”

"Ah," was the reply, "they may have subconsciously heard the conversation in the operating room, and their brain subconsciously translated the auditory information into a visual format."

“Okay,” I replied, “what about cases where people report reliable information about an event that took place far from their body?”

“Oh, it’s just a coincidence or a lucky guess,” they answer.

Losing my patience, I asked, “What does it take to convince you that this is true, maybe you yourself need to experience a near-death state?”

Quite unperturbed, without raising an eyebrow, my colleague replied: “Even if I myself experience such an experience, I will consider it a hallucination, but I will not believe that the mind can exist separately from the body.” He added that dualism (the philosophical thesis that states that mind and matter are independent substances, neither of which can be reduced to the other) is a false theory, and that there can be no proof that is false.

This was an important lesson for me, because before me was an educated, intelligent person who said that he would not leave materialism, no matter what happened. Even his own experiences will not force him to abandon materialism. At that moment, I realized two things. First, this experience weaned me from arguing such things with die-hard colleagues; there is no point in arguing with someone who claims that his views are already established, and he will not change them, no matter what I say.

Secondly, this experience taught me that it is important to distinguish between (a) materialism as an empirical hypothesis about the structure of the world, subject to evidence (this is a sign of a scientific hypothesis - that the facts are essential for its truth or falsity) and (b) materialism as an ideology or a paradigm about how "should" be, which is not subject to facts (this is a sign of an unscientific hypothesis - evidence is not essential for its truth).

My colleague believed in materialism not as a scientific hypothesis that could be wrong, but as a dogma or an ideology that "should" be true despite contradicting facts. For him, materialism is the fundamental paradigm in terms of which everything else is explained, but which itself is unquestionable.

I coined the term "fundamentalist" to refer to those who believe that materialism is an indisputable truth that is not subject to empirical evidence. I call it fundamental materialism for an unambiguous comparison with fundamentalism in religion. Fundamentalism implies the belief in the correctness of one's beliefs.

Just as the Christian fundamentalist is convinced that the world was created in the manner described in the Bible (despite the fossil record), the fundamentalist is convinced that everything that exists is made of matter or physical energy (regardless of the PSP and other evidence). In fact, and this is an important point, their respective belief has nothing to do with the actual evidence. As my fundamentalist colleague put it, "There can be no proof that is not true."

With respect to (a) materialism as an empirical hypothesis about the structure of the world, the evidence against is overwhelming. With respect to (b) materialism as an ideology, proofs are logically impossible. A complicating factor is that the fundamental materialist believes that his belief in materialism is not ideological but empirical. That is, he erroneously classifies himself in category (a), while his behavior clearly falls into category (b).

Skeptics believe that by ignoring and dismissing the evidence against materialism, they are demonstrating a "scientific" approach. But if asked what kind of empirical evidence would convince them that materialism is wrong, they, like my colleague, are usually at a loss as to what to say.

If they are not familiar with the data, then a criterion will be put forward, which, in fact, has already been met. If it is pointed out that there are many documented cases that satisfy the proposed criterion, they will simply make the criterion more stringent, and at some point cross the line between a reasonable requirement for scientific evidence and an unreasonable (and unscientific) requirement for logical evidence.

Courtesy of the Journal of Near-Death Studies. Dr. Neil Grossman holds a PhD in history and philosophy and is a faculty member at the University of Illinois, Chicago.

Share with friends or save for yourself:

Loading...